Capcom’s Monster Hunter collaboration with Magic: The Gathering should have been an easy win. Monster Hunter is a massive franchise with a huge global fan base, and Secret Lair drops are known for delivering exciting reprints, fresh artwork, and big collector hype. But this time, something feels off.
A press release from Capcom, posted briefly and then removed, revealed all the cards included in the upcoming Monster Hunter Secret Lair Super Drop. While the artwork is expected to be spectacular, the actual reprint value and card choices have left many players disappointed. This may be one of the weakest Secret Lair lineups in recent memory, and here is a complete breakdown of why fans feel let down.
The Hunt: Beautiful Art, Disappointing Reprints
The first bundle in the Super Drop is titled The Hunt, and it includes four cards paired with popular Monster Hunter creatures. Although the artwork will likely be visually stunning, the actual card value in this set is extremely low.
Blind Obedience features Malzeno from Monster Hunter Rise: Sunbreak, and while it is a solid card, it has a very low market price. Snap appears as Kushala Daora and remains a useful spell, but it is inexpensive. Village Rites is represented by Magnamalo and Tobi-Kadachi, but this is a card worth only a few cents and was an unusual choice considering more valuable alternatives were available. Mizzium Mortars paired with Yian Garuga adds very little in value as well. Tooth and Nail is arguably the most iconic spell in the drop and features Shagaru Magala and Seregios, but the card’s high casting cost keeps it from seeing extensive play in modern Commander decks.
Overall, The Hunt barely reaches ten dollars in total reprint value, despite being sold for thirty dollars non-foil and forty dollars foil. While the art may appeal to Monster Hunter fans, the gameplay and financial appeal of the cards are minimal.
The Hunters: Better Value, But Strange Choices
This bundle offers slightly better value than the others, making it the most reasonable drop in the entire collection, though it still does not fully justify the price.
Grand Abolisher, featuring Tigrex armor with Bone Scythes, is a strong and highly desired reprint and the highlight of the set. Rakdos Charm appears with Valstrax armor and offers utility, but has little monetary value. Grim Haruspex with Nargacuga armor is a good card for sacrifice-focused decks, but remains inexpensive. Imperial Recruiter is by far the most appealing inclusion, represented through a combination of armor sets, and is the primary contributor to this bundle’s overall value. Champion Lancer with Astalos armor is receiving alternate artwork for the first time, adding some collector interest.
This drop offers around twenty to twenty-five dollars in reprint value, making it better than the others, but still below the purchase cost. The card selection is serviceable, but the choices remain confusing for players expecting higher-impact reprints.
Monsters and Monsters II: Great Art, Weak Reprint Choices
The Monsters and Monsters II bundles feature a long list of Monster Hunter creatures mapped onto various Magic cards. While the artwork will undoubtedly be visually impressive, the card choices do not match player expectations for a crossover of this scale.
Nezahal, Primal Tide appears as Gore Magala, Drakuseth, Maw of Flames arrives as Rathalos, and Serra the Benevolent is depicted as Zinogre. Niv-Mizzet Reborn is mapped to Nergigante, Etali, Primal Storm is portrayed as Fatalis, Razaketh the Foulblooded appears as Gore Magala, Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider takes on Valstrax, and Brudiclad is shown as Brachydios. Although these are recognizable Monster Hunter creatures, many of the chosen Magic cards are either mid-value rares or creatures from preconstructed decks that do not command much excitement.
Fans expected much more from this collaboration. Popular Commander dragons such as The Ur-Dragon, Miirym, Scion of the Ur-Dragon, Tiamat, and other highly valued cards would have made perfect sense in a Monster Hunter crossover. The synergy between Monster Hunter’s legendary dragons and Magic’s fan-favorite dragon cards seemed like an obvious match. Instead, players received a scattered assortment of moderately useful creatures with low financial value.
Why Players Are Upset
Many fans are disappointed because the overall reprint value across the drops is weak compared to what players expect from a Secret Lair collaboration. Monster Hunter provides a rare opportunity to blend iconic dragons and monsters with Magic’s most beloved creature types, yet the card selections do not reflect the level of potential this crossover had. The artwork is clearly the main focus, leaving gameplay value secondary. For players who buy Secret Lairs for both aesthetics and card utility, this feels like a missed opportunity. Additionally, the pricing of thirty dollars per non-foil and forty dollars for foil versions does not feel justified when the majority of cards are low-value.
Final Thoughts: Is This the Weakest Super Drop Ever?
This Monster Hunter Secret Lair Super Drop could have been one of the most memorable collaborations Magic has ever done. The franchise aligns perfectly with Magic’s themes of dragons, monsters, and epic battles. The artwork will undoubtedly appeal to Monster Hunter fans, but for Magic players who expect a balance of art, gameplay value, and meaningful reprints, the drop falls short.
Collectors may still purchase these sets for the art alone, but players hoping for stronger reprints or high-impact Commander staples are likely to skip this release. While a few standout cards exist, they are not enough to offset a collection that feels more like a missed opportunity than a celebration of one of gaming’s most exciting franchises.
Also Read